Miliband defends Burnham slavery apology plan as reparations ruled out
Ed Miliband has defended Andy Burnham's plan to consider a slavery apology, saying the UK will not pay financial reparations and the approach will cost taxpayers nothing.
How it was covered
- GB News carried 86% of the airtime and concentrated on Rejecting reparations and debating an apology with Arley Gill.
- Sky News concentrated on Tom Tugendhat's argument against a fresh apology and summit distraction.
- Channel 4 concentrated on Miliband's defence of an apology with no reparations cost.
- Channel 5, BBC News, BBC One, BBC Two and ITV: not found in tracked broadcasts.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story. Facts only one channel reported are attributed to it.
Channel 4 reported that Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband had defended Prime Minister Andy Burnham's plan to consider a formal apology for Britain's role in the slave trade. It said Miliband stressed that the UK would not offer financial reparations and that the government's new approach would not cost the British taxpayer anything.
On 2 November, GB News reported that Burnham and his wife had arrived in Antigua for a Commonwealth summit and that he would join the King at a meeting where reparations campaigners had promised widespread protests. Sky News had reported earlier that King Charles was on a royal tour of the Caribbean and that Burnham was flying out later for the Commonwealth leaders' meeting.
GB News reported that Burnham was willing to discuss a formal apology while ruling out direct financial compensation. It also reported suggestions that he was open to increasing financial assistance for African and Caribbean countries, including investment in healthcare and education.
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch warned that an apology could open the door to demands for reparations, GB News reported. On Sky News, Tom Tugendhat, the shadow foreign secretary, said Tony Blair had apologised for Britain's role in slavery 25 years ago and that there should not be a rolling apology from every prime minister. He said debt relief at the Millennium was in some ways a form of reparations and argued that a reparations debate would dominate a two-day Commonwealth summit.
GB News also broadcast a monologue from presenter Jacob Rees-Mogg arguing that British taxpayers owe nothing for 18th-century slavery. He said Britain banned the slave trade in 1807 and abolished slavery across the British Empire in 1834, and that Britain had led the world in ending the trade. In an interview on the same programme, Arley Gill, chairman of the Grenada National Reparations Committee, disputed that account. He said chattel slavery in the Caribbean and the Americas was distinct because black people were treated as property, and cited a 1632 Barbados law as a precedent.
On its late programme, GB News reported that Burnham had previously said living British people should not be held legally liable for crimes committed by their ancestors. It also reported that Burnham had said sorry while the King had expressed sorrow but not said sorry. It said no reparations had been agreed, but there could be more schools and hospitals.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, grouped by how many channels reported each one. Select a dot to see the source excerpt.
| Claim | | | | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Widely reported · 3 or more of 4 channels | ||||
| Andy Burnham was travelling to a Commonwealth heads of government meeting. | Reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Reported by Sky News | |
| Reported by a few · 2 channels | ||||
| In a Guardian article ahead of the Commonwealth Leaders Summit, Andy Burnham indicated openness to a formal state apology for Britain's role in the transatlantic slave trade and offered talks with affected countries and campaign groups. | Reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Only on one channel | ||||
| Andy Burnham apologised for slavery and indicated he may issue further apologies. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Andy Burnham previously said living British citizens should not be legally liable for crimes committed by their ancestors. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Ed Miliband defended Andy Burnham's plan to consider a formal apology for Britain's role in slavery. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by GB News | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Kemi Badenoch warned that a formal apology could lead to demands for reparations. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Miliband said the UK would not offer financial reparations and the new approach would not cost taxpayers. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by GB News | Not reported by Sky News | |
| Newspaper front pages reported that Burnham would pay millions following a slavery row. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Reported by GB News | Not reported by Sky News |
| No reparations have been agreed yet, with additional schools and hospitals mentioned. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by Sky News | |
| The King expressed sorrow without issuing an apology. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Reported by GB News | Not reported by Sky News |
| Tom Tugendhat said Millennium debt relief was in some respects a form of reparations. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by GB News | Reported by Sky News |
| Tom Tugendhat said the reparations debate would dominate a two-day Commonwealth summit. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by GB News | Reported by Sky News |
| Tugendhat accused Andy Burnham of inconsistency, citing Burnham's positions on the EU and Chagos. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by GB News | |
| Tugendhat opposed a fresh slavery apology, arguing that Tony Blair had already apologised once for the UK and that there should not be a rolling apology from every new prime minister. | Not reported by BBC Two | Not reported by Channel 4 | Not reported by GB News | |
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
Sky News used an interview with Tom Tugendhat, the shadow foreign secretary, to frame the row around whether a fresh apology is needed. It stressed his view that Tony Blair had already apologised, that Millennium debt relief counted as a form of reparations, and that a reparations debate would crowd out a two-day Commonwealth summit. The segment was sceptical of a new apology and did not report the government's latest defence by Ed Miliband.
- “I think Tony Blair did it for the whole country. He did it once.”
- “the reparations that were in some ways paid with the debt relief at the Millennium”
- “in a two-day conference, this is going to literally dominate every ounce of breath”
GB News gave the story its most combative treatment, leading with Burnham's arrival in Antigua and reporting that he would discuss an apology while ruling out direct compensation. Its presenter Jacob Rees-Mogg delivered a monologue rejecting reparations, and the channel interviewed Arley Gill of the Grenada National Reparations Committee in a tense exchange. Its late programme returned to the row with a heated panel debate and claims about Burnham's previous position.
- “You, ladies and gentlemen, do not owe reparations to anybody for slavery.”
- “you do have a fundamental, mistaken view of the history of the Atlantic slave trade and slavery.”
- “We owe nothing for things that happened in the 18th century.”
Channel 4's short summary focused on the official line from Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, who defended the plan to consider an apology while ruling out financial reparations and any cost to taxpayers. It offered the most recent development in the coverage and did not carry the historical debate seen on GB News or the interview with Tugendhat on Sky News.
- “The Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has defended Andy Burnham's plan to consider a formal apology for Britain's role in trafficking slaves”
- “he stressed that the UK would not be offering financial reparations”
- “the government's new approach would not cost anything to the British taxpayer.”
Who was on air
People and organisations each channel put on air while covering this story. Channels' own presenters and reporters are not listed. Names as transcribed, and the list can miss people.
- 09:22 GMT
Tom Tugendhat, Shadow of Foreign Secretary
Mornings with Ridge and Frost · Mon 2 Nov
- 20:10 GMT
- 20:10 GMT
Arley Gill, chairman of the Grenada National Reparations Committee
Jacob Rees-Mogg's State Of The · Mon 2 Nov - 20:19 GMT
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.



