Nutritionists criticise viral carnivore diet over health and manosphere links
Nutritionists warn the viral carnivore diet is far outside health advice and lacks evidence, while its spread is tied to social media and manosphere ideas about meat and masculinity.
How it was covered
- Sky News was the only channel found covering it, concentrating on raw-meat influencers, health warnings and manosphere gender messaging.
- Channel 5, BBC News, BBC One, Channel 4, GB News and ITV: not found in tracked broadcasts.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story. Facts only one channel reported are attributed to it.
Sky News has reported on the viral carnivore diet, an all-animal-product regime with no vegetables and no carbohydrates, and the criticism it has attracted from nutrition experts. In a report by Victoria Seabrook, the channel examined how the diet has spread online and how ideas about masculinity and body image have helped promote it.
Sky News reported that a follower named Hassan Sadik eats raw liver and raw eggs and posts videos online under the name CarnivoreHass that get thousands of views. He said the diet has given him stable hunger levels and that people tell him he looks better, with improved skin. He also said he still has rheumatoid arthritis, has not been able to stop his medication and believes he has less inflammation overall.
According to Sky News, the diet flies in the face of NHS advice to cook food such as liver and chicken properly to kill dangerous bacteria. At a monthly meet-up in Kent, carnivores ate raw steak and raw chicken with lemon juice and kefir. Sky News said the diet grew out of medical desperation, but social media and notions of masculinity and body image helped it spread, often through an anti-establishment mindset and traditional gender roles.
Sky News reported that nutritionists warn the diet is far outside general health recommendations. One nutritionist said most evidence points to meat and animal products being less beneficial and that cutting out vegetables, whole grains and fruit would be more harmful. The same expert said there is not any strong evidence that extreme carnivore diets help specific health problems, and described them as an elimination stage that removes potential trigger foods but never reintroduces them.
Sky News reported that one poll of British men aged 16 to 34 found 41% frequently see online content linking meat to masculinity, while 28% often see posts mocking plant-based men with terms such as soy boy or weak. The environmental charity Hubbub has used a youth football tournament with West Bromwich Albion to try to stop these ideas taking root. According to Sky News, the charity is interested in young men because they eat more meat year on year and are targeted with information about high-meat diets, strength and an ideal body that is unrealistic on cost, environmental and health grounds.
Sky News reported that Hassan Sadik denied tying the diet to masculinity but said low testosterone in males can be improved by it. Doctors say there is no clinical evidence that the carnivore diet boosts testosterone. He said he does not get any financial benefit and was sharing his journey because it has helped him.
Sky News said food has become political in the wild west of social media, where algorithms exploit differences.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, grouped by how many channels reported each one. Select a filled dot (or logo) to see the source excerpt. A hollow dot (or faded logo) means the channel reported it but no excerpt is linked.
| Claim | |
|---|---|
| Only on one channel | |
| A survey of British men aged 16 to 34 reported that 41% frequently saw online content linking meat with masculinity and 28% often saw posts mocking plant-based men. | |
| Doctors state there is no clinical evidence that the carnivore diet increases testosterone. | |
| The carnivore diet consists exclusively of animal products, excluding vegetables and carbohydrates. | |
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
Sky News treated the carnivore diet as both a health story and a social-media phenomenon. Its report foregrounded raw-meat influencer Hassan Sadik, then set his claims against NHS food-safety advice and nutritionists' warnings. It also gave unusual space to the manosphere framing, including poll data on meat and masculinity and a charity project aimed at young men.
- “Yeah, it's quite far outside what we're recommending for general health.”
- “People trust the authority figures online and they don't do their own research.”
- “I don't tie it to masculinity.”
Who was on air
People and organisations each channel put on air while covering this story. Channels' own presenters and reporters are not listed. Names as transcribed, and the list can miss people.
- 11:32 GMT
Hassan Sadik, Fierce champion of the carnivore diet
Sky News Today With Matt Barbet · Sun 15 Nov
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.
