Lisa Nandy rejects criticism over Erasmus announcement on Remembrance Sunday
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has rejected Conservative and Reform UK criticism of announcing the UK's return to the Erasmus scheme on Remembrance Sunday.
How it was covered
- BBC One carried 59% of the airtime and concentrated on the Westminster row and the wider UK-EU deal details.
- BBC News concentrated on Nandy's defence, the Erasmus cost and Conservative and Reform criticism.
- Channel 5, Channel 4, GB News, ITV and Sky News: not found in tracked broadcasts.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story. Facts only one channel reported are attributed to it.
Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has rejected criticism from the Conservatives and Reform UK over the timing of the announcement that the UK will rejoin the Erasmus student exchange programme. The government linked restarting the scheme to honouring the courage of veterans on Remembrance Sunday. The Conservatives called that disrespectful to veterans. Reform UK accused ministers of politicising Remembrance Sunday.

In a report by Jack Fenwick, the scheme was described as allowing students from British universities to study abroad and vice versa, with some costs covered by the EU. The UK left Erasmus after Brexit but will return from January at a cost of £570 million. The Culture Department said it would give a generation of people the chance to build connections across Europe. BBC One West reported that the scheme would also give apprentices and adult learners exchange opportunities abroad.
Nandy denied that the timing was inappropriate. She said it was right to honour the legacy of that generation with more than "lip service" and with standing at the Cenotaph, important as that was. She said the government should educate a new generation about what that generation fought for and achieved. Reform UK said the Erasmus scheme was "wildly expensive" and benefits European students more than the UK. It said Nandy's use of Remembrance Sunday was in "very, very poor taste".
Andy Burnham wants a closer relationship with the EU. Later this month, he will announce a wider deal on youth movement. The EU is said to want access to the UK for 150,000 young Europeans, and the UK government is thought to be trying to negotiate that number down. Nandy accepted that closer ties would come with trade-offs.
BBC News reported that Europe's former chief Brexit negotiator said the UK could not pick and choose options, but that the door was open to rejoining the EU if it wanted. BBC One West named him as Michel Barnier and reported that he warned against cherry-picking. In a later package by Joe Pike, BBC One West said the new UK-EU deal was expected to include the removal of post-Brexit checks on food and animal exports, the linking of UK and EU carbon emissions trading schemes, and a youth experience programme allowing people to live, work and study on the continent. Reports differed on timing: BBC News said a major UK-EU summit was nine days away, while BBC One West said the new agreements were due to be signed off in 12 days.
BBC One West also quoted a lifelong Eurosceptic saying only a very small part of the economy, such as sellers of oysters or beef, would benefit. He said the UK would go on surrendering its fisheries for a further 10 years and pay an undisclosed sum that would not be insignificant.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, grouped by how many channels reported each one. Select a dot to see the source excerpt.
| Claim | | |
|---|---|---|
| Reported by all 2 channels | ||
| Lisa Nandy rejected criticism of linking the UK's return to the Erasmus scheme with Remembrance Sunday, while the Conservatives and Reform UK criticised the government's claim that restarting Erasmus would honour those who served. | ||
| The EU was reported to want access to the UK for 150,000 young Europeans, with the UK government thought to be trying to negotiate that number down. | Reported by BBC One | |
| The UK will rejoin the Erasmus scheme from January at a reported cost of £570 million. | ||
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
BBC One West framed the row as a Westminster political fight and later widened it to the UK's broader EU relationship. Joe Pike's package added the expected food, carbon and youth mobility elements of a new deal, plus a Eurosceptic warning on fisheries and payments. It carried Nandy's defence and the Conservative and Reform UK criticism.
- “I don't think we're promoting a deal with the EU at all.”
- “The Tories said Lisa Nandy's intervention was shameful. Reform UK said it was in poor taste.”
- “A very, very tiny part of the economy will like it if you're selling oysters or beef or things like that.”
BBC News led with Nandy's rejection of the criticism and the basic Erasmus terms: the £570 million cost and the January return. It also carried the Conservative and Reform UK attacks, Burnham's push for closer EU ties and the former negotiator's warning, but not the later BBC One West detail on the new deal.
- “If you look at the Erasmus scheme, wildly expensive and benefits European students more than us.”
- “It's right that we honour the legacy of that generation with more than lip service and standing at the Cenotaph as important as that is”
- “With a major UK-EU summit just nine days away, there's plenty of debate ahead about the UK's future relationship with Brussels and what that could mean for immigration.”
Who was on air
People and organisations each channel put on air while covering this story. Channels' own presenters and reporters are not listed. Names as transcribed, and the list can miss people.
- 15:19 GMT
Lisa Nandy, culture secretary
BBC News · Sun 8 Nov - 15:19 GMT
- 16:17 GMT
Lisa Nandy, Culture Secretary
BBC News · Sun 8 Nov - 16:17 GMT
- 16:18 GMT
- 16:18 GMT
Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
BBC News · Sun 8 Nov
- 13:07 GMT
Lisa Nandy, Culture Secretary
BBC News · Sun 8 Nov
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.

