Mountbatten beach closed due to asbestos in sand
Mountbatten beach in Plymouth was closed after high levels of asbestos were found in sand samples, prompting public health concerns.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story.
Mountbatten beach in Plymouth has been closed to the public after high levels of asbestos were found in sand samples. The closure, which came into effect immediately, has raised serious public health concerns and threatens to disrupt local businesses for a second time.
The discovery of asbestos on the beach is not new. It was first found seven years ago, leading to a temporary closure. At that time, officials decided the risk was low enough to allow people back, and the council has since sent contractors every couple of months to pick up the material. The source is concrete construction material containing asbestos, which has worn into small round pebbles that wash up onto the beach.
Recent testing, however, has revealed a far more widespread problem. Of 16 sand samples taken, 14 contained high levels of asbestos. The fibres, if inhaled, could pose a safety risk. As a result, the beach is now cordoned off with barriers, tape and fencing while authorities decide what to do next.
Local businesses are bracing for a repeat of the disruption they experienced in 2019. One cafe owner described the earlier closure as "devastating" and said her heart sank when she heard the news. She had started her business three years before that and lost an entire summer's trade. "This is what we use to bolster our trade in the winter," she said, fearing the same pattern will unfold again.
Plymouth City Council has acknowledged the severity of the situation. Further testing is scheduled for next week, followed by a full review of the whole peninsula to ensure no other areas are affected. A council spokesperson said public safety must be the priority, but admitted the beach could be closed for a "significant period". The council has already visited businesses on the peninsula to discuss their concerns.
Traders worry that while the beach is closed, visitors will find new favourite spots elsewhere, potentially causing long-term damage to their trade even after the beach reopens. The council has urged people to continue visiting the peninsula, noting that other attractions and the views remain open and beautiful.
On screen
Stills are sampled automatically at 60-second intervals. Where shown, the still is the nearest available frame from the relevant broadcast segment and is included to show what was on screen during that part of the broadcast. A still may not correspond to the exact second of a quoted phrase.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, mapped by channel. Ordered by how many channels carried each claim.
| Claim | ITV |
|---|---|
| Asbestos was first found on the beach seven years ago, leading to closure, but it was later deemed low risk and reopened. | |
| Recent tests found high asbestos levels in 14 of 16 sand samples. | |
| The council plans further testing next week and a full review of the peninsula. |
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
The report focused heavily on the impact on local businesses, particularly a cafe owner who experienced a similar closure in 2019. It also provided historical context about the asbestos problem and highlighted the uncertainty over how long the beach would remain closed. The tone was sympathetic to traders while reporting the council's public safety rationale.
- “I rolled my eyes because we've had this before in 2019 and it was such a devastating effect for everybody involved.”
- “When I heard the news first thing this morning, my heart completely sank because it was catastrophic for our business.”
- “What traders fear is that while the beach is closed and people are forced to go somewhere else they'll probably fall in love with a new favourite beach or a new favourite cafe or coffee stop and that this might have a long-term impact on their business.”
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.