White House accuses National Museum of American History of anti-Americanism
The White House has accused the National Museum of American History of anti-Americanism and demanded that the museum present a more celebratory version of US history.
The Full Story
A plain summary built from the channels that reported this story.
The White House has accused the National Museum of American History of anti-Americanism, demanding that the institution present a more celebratory version of US history. In a lengthy report, the administration criticised the museum for focusing on negative aspects of the American story, arguing that it should instead highlight what it called the victory of freedom and genius. The report accused the museum's leadership of adopting an ideological framework in which the American story is not celebrated but used to divide, dispirit, and discourage citizens.
The Smithsonian Institution, which runs the museum, hit back, citing its long record of non-partisan and independent scholarship. The dispute is part of a wider push by President Donald Trump to reshape how American history is taught and displayed. An executive order promising to restore truth and sanity to American history has already led to the removal of a slavery exhibit from a Philadelphia park and the scrubbing of images of black and minority war heroes from federal websites.
The White House report specifically criticised the museum for using history as a tool of social justice, for writing the words 'rights of woman' in larger type than 'rights of man', and for describing Christopher Columbus as a murderer. Many historians argue that Columbus was ruthless and responsible for brutality and death, but the report's author, Mike Gonzalez, wants the museum's leadership sacked, accusing them of being unpatriotic. He said the directors might as well hang a sign saying the exhibits were prepared by people who do not want you to love your country.
Visitors to the museum, however, expressed support for a more honest and complex portrayal of history. One Trump voter said the museum's current approach was not too negative, giving it an 85% rating, and argued that you have to talk about the negative or you are doomed to repeat it. Another visitor said: 'We have to remember history no matter how horrific it was so that way we don't repeat it.' The president of the Schocko Institute in Virginia, a state he described as ground zero for slavery, said real love of country means looking in the mirror and seeing yourself for the totality of who you are.
The debate has been raging since 2020, when some Black Lives Matter protesters tore down statues of Confederate figures. Trump had one such statue reinstalled. At Mount Rushmore last week, the president made clear he wants American history discussed triumphantly, calling the nation under God the best and most incredible thing ever to happen on this planet. The White House claims this is not about erasing the negative, but Trump did not mention the word slavery in his speech. The museum insists it provides a full arc of history, and visitors said they left feeling patriotic.
On screen
Stills are sampled automatically at 60-second intervals. Where shown, the still is the nearest available frame from the relevant broadcast segment and is included to show what was on screen during that part of the broadcast. A still may not correspond to the exact second of a quoted phrase.
Key Claims
Claims reported during this story's coverage, mapped by channel. Ordered by how many channels carried each claim.
| Claim | Channel 4 |
|---|---|
| The White House accused the National Museum of American History of anti-Americanism and demanded a more celebratory version of US history; the Smithsonian Institution defended the museum's record of non-partisan scholarship. |
Channel Perspectives
What each channel focused on, with key quotes.
Channel 4 News provided a balanced, in-depth report that included both the White House accusations and the museum's defence, as well as on-the-ground interviews with visitors and a historian. The tone was neutral but leaned towards supporting a nuanced, honest portrayal of history, highlighting that visitors and even a Trump voter favoured including negative aspects. The report also connected the museum dispute to broader Trump administration efforts to rewrite American history.
- “the White House accused the leaders of the National Museum of American History of thinly veiled anti-Americanism.”
- “You absolutely have to talk about the negative or you're, like I said, doomed to repeat it.”
- “the directors might as well hang a sign out the front door that says, Warning, the exhibits in this museum were prepared by people who do not want you to love your country.”
Broadcast Timeline
News broadcasts tracked for this story, in time order.